The teenage girl study was more peer to peer and the news outlet study was more server-side because the teenager girls were communicating whereas the researchers for the news outlets were simply looking at what people are doing. They did not need to have a conversation with the bloggers to find the answer.
Name of the Case:
“The Teenage Girl as Consumer and Communicator”
Online media were used by finding where the teenage girls are shopping and how they are getting information. Teenage girls used e-mails to learn about their favorite brands and sales promotions. Also, it turns out girls are telling other people about their favorite stores through Facebook and Twitter.“

Overall Communication Strategy was:
Very one-way/two-way= 4. I think that the overall communication strategy was two-way because most girls would receive an email about sales, but then discuss it with friends and family. It is very peer-to-peer.
Very asymmetrical/symmetrical= 2. It is more asymmetrical because it is unbalanced. Retail stores often get feedback from clients, but most times the organization does not change. Instead, the organizations want the buyers to change. Teen girls are actually patient and value-minded, with more than 60 percent of them generally waiting for items to go on sale before making a purchase; 77 percent are more likely to buy a sale-priced item than one at full price.
Very denotative/facilitative= 4. It is more facilitative. It is more facilitative because shopping is more of a dialogic communication process. Shopping is a way for people to hang out with best friends and have meaningful dialogue.
Very monologic/dialogic= 4. It is very dialogic. Dialogic communication requires real people to get and stay involved in the conversation. Shopping is a way for people to communicate and retail stores know this. In order for people to continue to shop, there needs to be some kind of dialogue. There is also dialogue in emails and social media sites.
Very market as targets/conversations= 4. I think it is based more on conversations. Retail stores and customers talked to each other. There was mass marketing, but I believe more dialogue was used.
Case 2:
Study finds traditional news outlets still leading blogs
Online media was used to figure out who was coming up with news stories first, blogs or traditional news outlets. Cornell Universtiy used the Web to track and measure the news cycle. (The process by which information becomes news, competes for attention, and then fades.)
Social media sites were also used. A professor of new media at Columbia said that the dynamics of the news cycle are very different, because of Twitter.”

Overall Communication Study was:
Very one-way/two-way= 2. It was more one-way because no one was responding back toward the study. It was only the people who were researching the information that responded. They looked at peoples blogs, but they were not commenting. The researchers were only trying to compare.
Very asymmetrical/symmetrical= 2. It was very asymmetrical because it was unbalanced communication. Researchers were not communicating with people, but were simply searching. There is no way this communication strategy was symmetrical.
Very denotative/facilitative= 3. This question is difficult to answer. It could be more facilitative because blogs are more of a dialogic communication and so is traditiona means of news outlets. However, during the research, there was no a lot of dialogue to these bloggers. However, the professor at Columbia claims that Twitter is changing the industry completely.
Very monologic/dialogic= 2. The study was more monologic. Again, the researchers were not talking to people, but rather researching blogs. There did not need to be a discussion.
Very markets as targets/conversations= 2. It is more markets as targets because there is not a lot of dialogue, but rather researchers were targeting bloggers.
The ratings do not necessarily mean that one has better public relations over the other. It just means that one was able to find out information by other means. Researchers could just look for the answer on popular news blogs rather than ask. The teenage girls needed to give their opinions in order for researchers to understand the best move.